Vinyl Windows vs. Aluminum Windows

As you shop for new home windows, it’s important to carefully consider the pros and cons each material offers. How will you new windows best suit your unique needs?

Of course, you want to choose a durable material that has the aesthetic flexibility to match your existing exterior design. Or perhaps you want to showcase a brand new look for your home? Let’s take a look at vinyl vs. aluminum windows and which material comes out on top.

Vinyl Windows vs. Aluminum Windows

There are plenty of things to consider as you are comparing vinyl and aluminum window materials. Everything from regional temperatures to the desired color and design style. These factors can all impact the final decision you make for your replacement window project. Here’s what you should consider as you try to make your choice:

Design Style

Vinyl offers a polished look to the exterior of your home compared to the utilitarian look aluminum can have. Vinyl windows can also be manufactured with a wood-grain appearance for those who love the look but hate the maintenance of real wood.

In addition, vinyl is manufactured as one piece, so if it gets scratched or chipped, it won’t be as visible. Aluminum windows are typically painted or powder-coated, so these same chips and scratches will be significantly more visible as the metal shows through.

Durability and Strength

Vinyl replacement windows are incredibly durable, surpassing aluminum counterparts. Offering superior resistance to scratching and marring, as well as denting, it’s easy to see why vinyl windows are still such a popular choice. Aluminum is slightly stronger than vinyl windows, but the difference isn’t too significant.

Window Maintenance

Maintenance concerns can certainly be a huge factor in your ultimate decision for replacement windows. Vinyl materials require minimal maintenance, needing only a mild soap and water wash 1-2 times a year. Corrosion isn’t an issue with vinyl and you won’t have to worry about vinyl pitting or fading. However, it may be a problem with aluminum from time to time.

You won’t ever have to repaint or restain your vinyl windows since they are manufactured with the same color throughout. Aluminum windows will require more significant maintenance as these windows have moving parts. They need to be lubricated regularly. If painted, your aluminum windows will also need routine touch-ups between re-painting.


In most cases, aluminum windows are more expensive unless you choose the most basic of products. Vinyl is often the more affordable option and offers a better value for the cost of your window replacement project.


When looking for performance, vinyl simply can’t be beaten. Vinyl offers a considerable amount of benefits when it comes to performance, including:

  • superior noise reduction
  • excellent heat transfer resistance
  • less condensation
  • industry’s top choice for energy efficiency

Compare Quotes

If you’re trying to figure out whether or not vinyl windows are the right option for you, it’s highly recommended that you get in touch with a local professional. With some expert input, you will be able to figure out your options and choose the window that will best suit your lifestyle and unique requirements.